Healing a Country Divided
An artist's depiction of baseball in a Civil War camp |
Following the war the country needed healing in every aspect, and just as it had raised morale during the war, baseball helped to mend a country split in two. The Cincinnati Red Stockings became the first professional team in 1869 and the game soon became a distinct part of America's identity.
WWI and the Black Sox
The United States had been involved in several wars since the Civil War, perhaps most notably the Spanish-American War, but none of those would compare to World War I. Thankfully that war ended in 1918, four years after it began, and it was nowhere near as tragic as the Civil War had been for the US. That being said, it was still a war and the country still needed to be healed.
But baseball, instead of working to heal America, nearly destroyed its trust in the game just a few decades after it began.
The 1919 Chicago White Sox were one of the best teams ever to play baseball to that point. They were led by Shoeless Joe Jackson and a long list of other stars with virtually no holes in their lineup. They came into the World Series as the heavy favorites over the Cincinnati Reds, but little did the general public know, first baseman "Chick" Gandil had organized a fix. The Sox lost the Series 5-3, but ended up losing so much more. Eventually eight players from that team were found guilty of fixing the Series by betting against themselves and throwing games. Those eight were banned from the game for life. The scandal earned that team a new nickname, the Black Sox, and the integrity of the game had been greatly compromised for the first time.
But I suppose the legacy the Sox left behind isn't all bad. After all, the hero of that era, and the greatest player ever to lift a bat, actually patterned his swing after Shoeless Joe. (And by the way, I still think Jackson was innocent in terms of the fix, but that's a story for another day).
Just when baseball was losing America's trust, and just when baseball needed a hero, America was introduced to the greatest baseball player of all time: Babe Ruth.
Never before or since has there been a player as dominant as the Great Bambino. He was a good pitcher even before he became a legendary hitter. He set records, left curses, built stadiums, called shots, and almost a hundred years later we still consider him the greatest ball player of all time. Baseball fans of that era had a player they could cheer for, and it helped heal the hurt of war and scandal. Babe Ruth was the perfect cure for baseball and for America.
WWII
You want heroes? How about the 500 big league baseball players who left the game to serve our country in World War II? In the same year that saw the last .400 hitter in Ted Williams and one of the most untouchable baseball records in Joe DiMaggio's 56 game hitting streak, we also saw players drafted and voluntarily signing up for service in the military.
And it wasn't just backups or role players, there were superstars of the game who left fame and glory to defend America's freedom. Williams and Joltin' Joe both interrupted their legendary careers, as well as other future Hall of Famers such as Bob Feller, who rushed to enlist as soon as he heard about the attack on Pearl Harbor.
Many were critical that baseball was continuing on during the war. Some believed that these able bodied ball players should be serving their country and that baseball should not continue. However, one soldier, Private Clifford Mansfield, was quoted as saying "Baseball is part of the American way of life. Remove it and you remove something from the lives of American citizens, soldiers, and sailors. For the morale of the soldier and the morale of America itself, 'keep 'em playing'."
Baseball helped keep America's spirits high during the war, and the heroes who served our country with honor returned and gave the country even greater cause to cheer for them.
A Hero for Change
But in the aftermath of World War II there was still a significant problem in baseball: it was still a white man's game. There were no black players to be found in the Major Leagues but rather had to play in the Negro Leagues, which did well in their own right with players such as Satchel Paige, Roy Campanella, Willie Mays, and of course, Jackie Robinson.
The hero the African American community needed arrived on the big league scene in 1947 and took it by storm. In spite of intense persecution and abuse, Robinson became the Rookie of the Year hitting .297 with 12 home runs and a league leading 29 stolen bases. He went on to have a fantastic career with All Star appearances in six of his ten season. He won the MVP award and batting title in 1949.
More importantly he broke the color barrier that would change the game of baseball forever. Major League Baseball was no longer white, it was on its way to being fully integrated and a true representation of the best America had to offer. It was now truly a national pastime, minorities included.
And by the way, if you haven't seen "42," change that. Now.
The Strike
The 1994 and 1995 Major League Baseball seasons were marred by a player's strike that left baseball fans everywhere frustrated and outraged. The 1994 playoffs and World Series were cancelled, the pinnacle of the worst work stoppage in professional sports history.
Tony Gwynn, Larry Walker, Craig Biggio, and Jeff Bagwell were among the many players who helped heal us in the '90s after we lost a little trust and faith in the game. But in my mind there are two players that really stood above the rest in making the game important to us again, and for two entirely different reasons: Cal Ripken Jr. and Ken Griffey Jr.
Cal Ripken Jr. was known as "Iron Man" for his ability to consistently stay in the lineup. He fought off several injury scares and managed stay in the lineup for 16 consecutive years. Along that road he managed to break one of those unbreakable records: Lou Gehrig's streak of 2,130 consecutive games played.
Ripken's streak was actually threatened by the strike when owner's were threatening to use replacement players to complete the season. Perhaps recognizing the importance of The Streak to the game of baseball, Orioles owner Peter Angelos made it clear he would rather forfeit the remainder of the season than see Ripken's streak come to an end, and fortunately it never came to that. What made Cal Ripken Jr., and baseball for that matter, special was watching him shatter Lou Gehrig's record. He surpassed the record in 1996, the first complete season after the strike, and finally took himself out of the lineup after 2,632 consecutive games in 1998. Ripken was a Hall of Fame player regardless of The Streak, but this legendary record cemented his legacy and helped ignite baseball passion around the country.
What made Ken Griffey Jr. a hero? Quite simply he was the best baseball player America had seen in a really, really long time. The Kid was the epitome of a five tool ball player. He could throw, field, run, hit, and most of all he could hit with power. He was a 13 time All Star, won a Gold Glove in every year of the 1990s, and earned seven Silver Slugger awards. He is the only three-time winner of the Home Run Derby and hit over 40 home runs on seven different occasions, hitting 56 in 1997 and 1998. Junior finished his career with 630 dingers, good for fourth all time (if you exclude Barry Bonds and Alex Rodriguez, which I do).
It amazes me that in spite of all those statistics he only earned one MVP award in his career. Regardless of that he earned enough honors and was so dominant during the '90s he is arguably the greatest player of this generation. With probably the prettiest swing in the history of the game, an incredible amount of talent, and a personality that told us all he was just having fun out there, he was virtually everyone's favorite player of the 1990s. Having a superstar like Griffey made us miss baseball during the player's strike and excited us when it came back. Junior was the kind of hero baseball deserves in every generation.
**********
And now here we are, hopefully on the tail end of the steroid era. Fans are losing a lot of interest in baseball, particularly the younger generation (more women 50 or older watched last year's World Series than men under 50). Part of the problem may be the slower pace of the game or the feeling we get that baseball is stuck in tradition with an unwillingness to change and progress, which has valid arguments on both sides. But one of the largest reasons is that people have lost faith in the players. Sacred records have been broken by cheaters leaving us confused as to who the true home run kings are. Is Roger Maris the single season home run leader with 61, or are juiced up Sammy Sosa (66), Mark McGwire (70), and Barry Bonds (73) all ahead of him in the record books? Does Hammerin' Hank Aaron own the career mark with 755, or is Bonds the Home Run King with 762?
Bonds, McGwire, Sosa, Roger Clemens, Jason Giambi, Ryan Braun, Alex Rodriguez... The list goes on and on and on, filled with superstars who violated our trust by using performance enhancing drugs. At first we thought they were legends in the making. Now their names are forever tainted for lying to us and violating the sacredness of baseball. The game has lost a lot of fans, some we have no hope of recovering, but if baseball has any hope of continuing on as the American Pastime we need a Babe Ruth or a Ken Griffey Jr. We need someone to make a run at a sacred and unbreakable record (DiMaggio's hit streak?). We need someone who takes the game by storm. We may even need a whole army of them.
Sure we have Miguel Cabrera, last year's Triple Crown winner, the first since 1967. Sure we have Chris Davis, who hit home runs in the first half of the season at an alarming rate, though he's slowed considerably since the All-Star break. Sure we have Yasiel Puig, who broke onto the big league scene with some major noise back in June.
But none of them are the legend we need. At least not yet.
Maybe he's in the League already, maybe he isn't. But hopefully we find him, or them soon. Who will it be? Cabrera? Davis? Puig? Mike Trout? Bryce Harper? Stephen Strasburg?
We need to step into another golden age of baseball, and we need our heroes to be clean beyond a shadow of a doubt. I don't know what it's going to take, but we need a legendary player, or players, that we can trust. Maybe then our faith in the players and love of the game will be restored.
WWI and the Black Sox
The United States had been involved in several wars since the Civil War, perhaps most notably the Spanish-American War, but none of those would compare to World War I. Thankfully that war ended in 1918, four years after it began, and it was nowhere near as tragic as the Civil War had been for the US. That being said, it was still a war and the country still needed to be healed.
But baseball, instead of working to heal America, nearly destroyed its trust in the game just a few decades after it began.
![]() |
Shoeless Joe Jackson of the 1919 Chicago Black Sox |
But I suppose the legacy the Sox left behind isn't all bad. After all, the hero of that era, and the greatest player ever to lift a bat, actually patterned his swing after Shoeless Joe. (And by the way, I still think Jackson was innocent in terms of the fix, but that's a story for another day).
Just when baseball was losing America's trust, and just when baseball needed a hero, America was introduced to the greatest baseball player of all time: Babe Ruth.
Never before or since has there been a player as dominant as the Great Bambino. He was a good pitcher even before he became a legendary hitter. He set records, left curses, built stadiums, called shots, and almost a hundred years later we still consider him the greatest ball player of all time. Baseball fans of that era had a player they could cheer for, and it helped heal the hurt of war and scandal. Babe Ruth was the perfect cure for baseball and for America.
WWII
You want heroes? How about the 500 big league baseball players who left the game to serve our country in World War II? In the same year that saw the last .400 hitter in Ted Williams and one of the most untouchable baseball records in Joe DiMaggio's 56 game hitting streak, we also saw players drafted and voluntarily signing up for service in the military.
And it wasn't just backups or role players, there were superstars of the game who left fame and glory to defend America's freedom. Williams and Joltin' Joe both interrupted their legendary careers, as well as other future Hall of Famers such as Bob Feller, who rushed to enlist as soon as he heard about the attack on Pearl Harbor.
Many were critical that baseball was continuing on during the war. Some believed that these able bodied ball players should be serving their country and that baseball should not continue. However, one soldier, Private Clifford Mansfield, was quoted as saying "Baseball is part of the American way of life. Remove it and you remove something from the lives of American citizens, soldiers, and sailors. For the morale of the soldier and the morale of America itself, 'keep 'em playing'."
Baseball helped keep America's spirits high during the war, and the heroes who served our country with honor returned and gave the country even greater cause to cheer for them.
A Hero for Change
![]() |
Jackie Robinson stole home in Game 1 of the 1955 World Series |
The hero the African American community needed arrived on the big league scene in 1947 and took it by storm. In spite of intense persecution and abuse, Robinson became the Rookie of the Year hitting .297 with 12 home runs and a league leading 29 stolen bases. He went on to have a fantastic career with All Star appearances in six of his ten season. He won the MVP award and batting title in 1949.
More importantly he broke the color barrier that would change the game of baseball forever. Major League Baseball was no longer white, it was on its way to being fully integrated and a true representation of the best America had to offer. It was now truly a national pastime, minorities included.
And by the way, if you haven't seen "42," change that. Now.
The Strike
The 1994 and 1995 Major League Baseball seasons were marred by a player's strike that left baseball fans everywhere frustrated and outraged. The 1994 playoffs and World Series were cancelled, the pinnacle of the worst work stoppage in professional sports history.
Tony Gwynn, Larry Walker, Craig Biggio, and Jeff Bagwell were among the many players who helped heal us in the '90s after we lost a little trust and faith in the game. But in my mind there are two players that really stood above the rest in making the game important to us again, and for two entirely different reasons: Cal Ripken Jr. and Ken Griffey Jr.
Cal Ripken Jr. was known as "Iron Man" for his ability to consistently stay in the lineup. He fought off several injury scares and managed stay in the lineup for 16 consecutive years. Along that road he managed to break one of those unbreakable records: Lou Gehrig's streak of 2,130 consecutive games played.
![]() |
Ripken rounding the bases after homering in the fourth inning the day he broke Lou Gehrig's record |
Ripken's streak was actually threatened by the strike when owner's were threatening to use replacement players to complete the season. Perhaps recognizing the importance of The Streak to the game of baseball, Orioles owner Peter Angelos made it clear he would rather forfeit the remainder of the season than see Ripken's streak come to an end, and fortunately it never came to that. What made Cal Ripken Jr., and baseball for that matter, special was watching him shatter Lou Gehrig's record. He surpassed the record in 1996, the first complete season after the strike, and finally took himself out of the lineup after 2,632 consecutive games in 1998. Ripken was a Hall of Fame player regardless of The Streak, but this legendary record cemented his legacy and helped ignite baseball passion around the country.
What made Ken Griffey Jr. a hero? Quite simply he was the best baseball player America had seen in a really, really long time. The Kid was the epitome of a five tool ball player. He could throw, field, run, hit, and most of all he could hit with power. He was a 13 time All Star, won a Gold Glove in every year of the 1990s, and earned seven Silver Slugger awards. He is the only three-time winner of the Home Run Derby and hit over 40 home runs on seven different occasions, hitting 56 in 1997 and 1998. Junior finished his career with 630 dingers, good for fourth all time (if you exclude Barry Bonds and Alex Rodriguez, which I do).
![]() |
Junior watching one of his many long balls |
It amazes me that in spite of all those statistics he only earned one MVP award in his career. Regardless of that he earned enough honors and was so dominant during the '90s he is arguably the greatest player of this generation. With probably the prettiest swing in the history of the game, an incredible amount of talent, and a personality that told us all he was just having fun out there, he was virtually everyone's favorite player of the 1990s. Having a superstar like Griffey made us miss baseball during the player's strike and excited us when it came back. Junior was the kind of hero baseball deserves in every generation.
**********
And now here we are, hopefully on the tail end of the steroid era. Fans are losing a lot of interest in baseball, particularly the younger generation (more women 50 or older watched last year's World Series than men under 50). Part of the problem may be the slower pace of the game or the feeling we get that baseball is stuck in tradition with an unwillingness to change and progress, which has valid arguments on both sides. But one of the largest reasons is that people have lost faith in the players. Sacred records have been broken by cheaters leaving us confused as to who the true home run kings are. Is Roger Maris the single season home run leader with 61, or are juiced up Sammy Sosa (66), Mark McGwire (70), and Barry Bonds (73) all ahead of him in the record books? Does Hammerin' Hank Aaron own the career mark with 755, or is Bonds the Home Run King with 762?
![]() |
We could use another baseball legend like the greatest legend of all time: Babe Ruth |
Sure we have Miguel Cabrera, last year's Triple Crown winner, the first since 1967. Sure we have Chris Davis, who hit home runs in the first half of the season at an alarming rate, though he's slowed considerably since the All-Star break. Sure we have Yasiel Puig, who broke onto the big league scene with some major noise back in June.
But none of them are the legend we need. At least not yet.
Maybe he's in the League already, maybe he isn't. But hopefully we find him, or them soon. Who will it be? Cabrera? Davis? Puig? Mike Trout? Bryce Harper? Stephen Strasburg?
We need to step into another golden age of baseball, and we need our heroes to be clean beyond a shadow of a doubt. I don't know what it's going to take, but we need a legendary player, or players, that we can trust. Maybe then our faith in the players and love of the game will be restored.
OK, so I have a bunch of thoughts on this.
ReplyDeleteI don't think you can compare numbers straight up across eras anyway. It's not just steroids that changed that: black players, the height of the mound, weight training, and other changes have affected player's statistics, too, over the years, and so the records are not as telling as some think.
For example, Roger Maris may not have used steroids, but playing in more games is obviously an advantage for a statistic like total home runs in a season, just like playing in "just" 143 games was an advantage for Ted Williams in batting .406.
Steroids are tough, I think. If MLB had a problem with its precious record book being tainted, maybe they should have banned steroids earlier? I think it's ridiciulous, in retrospect, to hold only players accountable for this, when owners and Bud Selig were happy to make money off the home run races, too chicken to include steroid testing in any CBA, and way too late in cleaning up the sport. (Yes, steroids are illegal…but isn't that more of a reason they should have been cleaning up the game?)
Barry Bonds not being in the Hall of Fame is ridiculous. Absurd. Why even have one? My theory with Bonds is that he started using in 1999, out of jealousy after the McGwire-Sosa summer, and that's why he was fighting injuries that season. And in a way his jealousy makes sense, because in all reality he was a far better player than either of them. I think he was the best player of the 90s, and well on his way to being the best LF ever, even before the steroids.
I get what you're saying about his home run totals against Griffey, but I'm not sure Jr. would've had more even if Bonds hadn't used. Bonds was at 411 after 1998, and while he was 34, the guy was also a genetic freak (like Griffey) who took care of himself. And he got walked a LOT in his prime home run years—his totals would have been eveb higher if everyone wasn't so afraid of him. If he, hypothetically, still plays into his early 40s and gets an extra couple seasons of plate appearances back, I'm not sure he wouldn't have hit 220 more homers anyway.
At a minimum this is like having a basketball Hall of Fame that doesn't have Oscar Robertson in it. Maybe worse. The fact that we expect the writers who vote to have more backbone than the men who ran the sport in the 90s is stupid.
As for Shoeless Joe, my favorite take on him was: http://espn.go.com/classic/s/2001/0730/1232950.html
I'm one of the people that has lost interest. I rarely watch games on tv and major league game tickets are ridiculously overpriced. I much prefer going to minor league games...good fun without the prima donnas. I don't know enough about the current players to render an opinion on who could be the next hero. I do cheer for Bryce Harper to do well, though. I enjoyed reading this, Tim. Throw some history in there and I'm especially interested :)
ReplyDeletePrince Michael - I agree with you on pretty much everything there, especially when it comes to how MLB handled steroids. I'm almost equally upset with Selig as I am with the players guilty of cheating. It's like Selig woke up one morning just last year and said "I should probably start caring about steroids now that my indifference is costing the league money."
ReplyDeleteWhen it comes to Barry Bonds, I think if Shoeless Joe, and by the way some of the defensive stats and observations in that article I had never read and have me rethinking my perspective on him, and Pete Rose are banned for life for mistakes they made late in their careers, then cheaters such as Bonds should be as well. I agree that Bonds didn't start using until sometime around 1999, and I agree that he would have been a Hall of Famer without the 'roids, and may have ended up in the top three of home runs. But fact of the matter is he cheated. I don't know what the solution is because he certainly was one of the greatest players of all time, but we just don't know where he would have ended without steroids. If we let at least Pete into Cooperstown, then I'll listen to arguments on Bonds.
I understand what you're saying about Bonds. I don't think he was so good that we should ignore cheating, certainly.
ReplyDeleteBut I guess my question has always been: did he cheat? I mean, if steroids weren't against the rules, then he wasn't actually cheating. I always assumed they hadn't been against the rules when Bonds played, but I just looked on Wikipedia and saw that, "In 1991, Commissioner Fay Vincent sent a memo to all teams stating that steroid use was against the rules", so I guess I'm wrong? On the other hand, there was no testing and no enforcement and no speicifc punishments in case they ever started testing or if someone was caught in some other way. Plus, a memo is not exactly the rulebook, so I'm not sure. I tend to fall on the side of saying what Bonds did wasn't against the rules when he did it, which would mean he didn't cheat. And part of me thinks the perfect way to memorialize Selig and the other owners is to put Bonds in the Hall as a monument to their spinelessness. Sort of a, "We'd love to keep this guy out, but we can't, because they put short-term profits ahead of the game", that sort of thing. Whereas if you let them whitewash history now, and keep Bonds out, then they get to have it both ways, raking in the cash AND pretending to have the moral high ground, like they were the NCAA or something.
Having said that: Pete Rose?! Dude bet on Reds games as manager. Took him 15 years to admit it. Did he ever even apologize? Why should baseball forgive him? Unlike steroids, with the Black Sox scandal MLB actually had some principles and took the issue seriously, and Rose knew that going in. I wouldn't even start having this conversation until he shows at least a little contrition.
Dude bro dude. Why you gotta be hatin' on Bonds. As Mike pointed out, the guy was ridiculous even before the 'roids. 3 MVPs in four years by 1993. Not to mention he is the only guy steal 500 bases and hit 500 homeruns. I mean yikes. The guys was a beast. Not to mention that no one has been a been able to prove he ever "knowingly" took steroids (which is obviously a load of garbage).
ReplyDeleteI say put him, Rose, Jackson, and Clemens in the Hall. I'm not entirely sold on Sosa and McGwire because there's not a lot of evidence that they were any good without th juice.
Last point: a blatant snub to Buster Posey who won the Rookie of the Year, MVP, and 2 World Series in his first 3 years as a pro and one of those he sat out all year.
Yeah I'm a homer but you gotta respect the Giants.
Mike - I see where you're coming from, but I still gotta call it cheating. And as far as Pete Rose, an apology would be nice. But does what he did as a manager cancel out the fact he is the Hit King as a player? I don't know. And to be honest it wouldn't surprise me if he bet on games as a player, too, so maybe you're right. But it's a sticky situation.
ReplyDeleteTodd - I agree with you that Bonds was a phenom even before juicing, but I guess the way I see it is if Pete Rose was banned for something he did after playing, and something that didn't even affect him as a player, then why should Bonds get in for something that obviously did affect his abilities? I think Bonds is an idiot for tainting what would have already been a Hall of Fame career, but I suppose that's besides the point.
As for Buster Posey, my apologies. What he did in his first three years in the league was remarkable, and he could turn out to be one of the best catchers in the history of the game, so add him to the list of potential heroes of the game.